Navigating the Insurance Maze

The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should

with Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Navigating the Insurance Maze

The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should

with Barbara Griswold, LMFT

=

Updated July 23, 2026

I recently traveled to Washington state to meet Susan Frager from PsychBillingCoach.com. I have turned to Susan for years, whenever I don’t know an answer (I know, you thought I had all the answers, but I don’t).  But I had never met her in person.

Susan’s name is familiar to many of my readers. She knows more than I could ever hope to know about credentialing, billing, audits, and denials, plus she has a remarkable ability to navigate the complexities of the Medicare maze.

As we relaxed in her sunroom, with her beagle Spencer lounging in her lap, we traded stories about insurance denials and audits (yes, that’s what insurance consultants do when relaxing).  Then Susan shared something I didn’t know.

While I’ve always emphasized the importance of creating your session note soon after the session, what I didn’t know was that your session note really should be completed and signed before submitting an insurance claim or giving out a superbill for the session. It isn’t a good idea to bill for the session today and write your note when you’re gobbling down lunch tomorrow or when you are playing “note-catch-up” on the weekend. In fact, there could be big consequences if you do.

OK, I know this will bring up questions, so let’s address them.

“Why is this a big deal?”

I didn’t know this, but Medicare and Medicaid regulations specifically require medical records to be finalized before a claim is submitted, both to prove “medical necessity” and that the service was actually rendered. And some private insurance companies follow Medicare’s lead in this regard.

A previous version of this article discussed whether it could be considered fraud if you submitted the claim before documenting.  But this is not a debate that is useful, as you shouldn’t be worried that you are going to be taken to court for fraud.  But….

“So, exactly what could happen if I bill before documenting?” 

If you are audited, the health plan will look closely at your records.  The plan COULD compare the date the claim was submitted with the date when the note was written.  If the claim was submitted long before the date the note was written, the claim could be denied, or you could be forced to pay money back to the plan.  

“Are health plans REALLY clawing back money due to this?” 

Well, let’s be realistic: If this is the only issue with your notes, it probably won’t lead them to deny payment, so breathe.  But if there are other issues with your notes, AND they also see this kind of issue where you’ve backdated or written late notes, this latter issue may give them more reasons to deny your claims.  Plus this kind of irregularity could make them look more closely at your other notes.  The audit could widen, leading them to investigate a larger number of your previously submitted claims.  

“This doesn’t affect me – my Electronic Health Record (EHR) forces me to finish my note before submitting a claim.” 

Ah well, that’s true for most modern EHRs.   But some of you all-too-clever folks are bypassing this built-in protection as you rush to submit the claim.  Let’s talk about some of the creative ways you are doing that:

  • You write a “placeholder” note – also called a “dummy note.”  The therapist may write one sentence in the client note and sign/lock it.  This may be enough to “fool” the EHR and allow the claim to be issued.  The problem is that on the weekend or later in the month when you finish your note, you are now actually writing a late note – which may be frowned upon in a health plan audit.  Or the EHR may change the timestamp on the note to reflect the revision date.  To an auditor, says Susan, this could look as if you wrote the new note to match the claim or because you were being audited.
  • You’ve figured out how to “trick” your EHR software into decoupling the calendar appointment from the clinical documentation, enabling the program to generate a claim without checking for a note lock.  
  • You bypass the completed note requirement by manually submitting claims to the health plan via an external clearinghouse like Office Ally or Trizetto, where claims can be submitted without relying on notes being completed first. Then, in the EHR, you may check “”Submitted Externally” or “Billed Outside System.”
  • In group practices, a group administrator or biller could even have override privileges, allowing claims to be pushed through without session notes.

“This doesn’t affect me. I only give my clients superbills.”   

The same issue applies to you.  When a provider generates a superbill without completed documentation, they are still creating a document to be presented to the payer that attests that a service took place — and was documented. Certainly out-of-network therapists have much less chance of having records requested by the health plan, but it can happen.  I have always encouraged out-of-network clinicians to have a sentence in their informed consent that they cannot guarantee that their documentation will meet insurance plan criteria.

“Can’t I just backdate the session note to the date I submitted the claim?” 

Backdating a session note to make it appear as if you wrote it on the day of the session is typically considered fraud.  If you write a session note for a session that took place in the past, you must clearly identify in the note the date that you wrote the note. 

“So, you are saying I need to hold claims until I complete session notes?”   

Well, I worry that after reading this, some of you who are behind in your notes will now hold their claims, and will fall behind in filing them. This can be a double whammy, and cause significant financial distress. I don’t want that, of course. It would be better to file a claim and complete your notes as soon as possible afterwards.  

But I hope that this article motivates you to figure out how to stay on top of session notes.  What I want you to focus on is that timely notes are more than just a clinical best practice; they are directly tied to your ability keep your money if the auditor comes knocking.

The takeaway

  1. Don’t get paralyzed. Focus on a plan going forward, to carve out time to do your session notes each day.
  2. Dare to be adequate.  If you are a perfectionist, and tend to avoid notes or write too much, I get it! The hardest challenge for those of us who are perfectionists may be writing adequate brief but complete notes. An adequate but complete note is always better than no note, or an incomplete note.
  3. Consider whether doing paper notes would work better for you. I sell a downloadable notes template that may help you to get unstuck, and to write brief and complete notes — it is available here.
  4. Make keeping up with notes an ongoing priority.  Because you need (and deserve) to be paid in a timely manner for the awesome work that you do, it may be time to make catching up and keeping up with notes a priority. If you struggle with this, learn to write brief but thorough notes by taking my course “What’s Missing From Your Charts: Writing Great Notes,” available here.  My note template is free with this course.

And if you need help catching up on notes, schedule a consultation with Maelisa McCaffrey of qaprep.com — that’s her jam.

And finally, since I no longer do consultations, I highly recommend Susan Frager as a resource for issues other than session notes.  She can help you with an amazing array of insurance plan issues that makes you tear your hair out, including credentialing, claims, Medicare enrollment or billing, fighting a denial, writing appeal letters, even choosing billing programs.  Schedule your consultation with Susan and check out her online courses at psychbillingcoach.com.

Get Your Free Copy of the Report

"13 Ways You Might Be Accidentally Committing Insurance Fraud"

Your information will not be shared.

Writing Great Progress Notes Course

WEBINAR: "WHAT'S MISSING FROM YOUR CHARTS: WRITING GREAT NOTES" (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Practice Forms Packet

PRACTICE FORMS PACKET – 24 Essential Forms (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Navigating the Insurance Maze - Cover

2025 10th EDITION! Book: Navigating the Insurance Maze: The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Did you find this article helpful? For more like it, subscribe to Barbara's free e-newsletter here.

Barbara Griswold, LMFT, is a private practice coach and the author of Navigating the Insurance Maze: The Therapist's Complete Guide to Working With Insurance – And Whether You Should, 10th edition. Check out Barbara's online catalog of helpful online courses, practice forms, and other therapist resources related to insurance, documentation, and running your therapy business here.