Navigating the Insurance Maze

The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should

with Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Navigating the Insurance Maze

The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should

with Barbara Griswold, LMFT

More Clinician Pay Cuts? Aetna Flattens Alma Providers

(Post updated June 12th and July 13, 2026 — see updates in red at end of post)

Feeling a little déjà vu?

Yes—another health plan has found a new way to lower clinician reimbursement rates.

This time, it’s insurance giant Aetna. The company has rolled out new rate cuts for providers working through Alma, a membership-based billing platform with more than 24,000 licensed mental health clinicians across all 50 states.  Independent practitioners use the Alma platform to credential with and to bill health plans such as Aetna.

What’s new

This week, Alma emailed clinicians announcing reimbursement changes coming from Aetna starting July 15, 2026:

  • CPT code 90837 for 53+ minute sessions will be paid at the same rate as CPT code 90834 (Note: the email erroneously stated the 90834 code was for 37-52 minute sessions, yet this code is actually for 38–52 minute sessions).
  • Rates for 90834 and 90837 will also stop varying by degree type. In other words, psychotherapy sessions billed by doctoral-level psychologists will be reimbursed at the same rate as sessions billed by master’s-level providers.
  • On the medical side, Aetna will be reimbursing Evaluation and Management (E/M) code 99215 (high complexity visits) at the same rate as 99214 (moderate complexity visits), and pay MDs the same as Nurse Practitioners.  

Alma’s reaction

Alma says it disagrees with the changes, arguing that they do not reflect the specialized training and clinical expertise doctoral-level providers bring to their work or the value of longer sessions when they are clinically appropriate.  Alma’s position is that reimbursement should better reflect both of those factors.  

So, why is Alma going along with it?

Alma is an administrative and billing platform, not an insurance plan, so theoretically it must follow the fee schedules and policies set by Aetna. If Aetna updates its provider terms, Alma is contractually required to apply and enforce those changes. If Alma refused, it would be violating its contract with Aetna.  

This also isn’t the first major shake-up involving Alma’s 90837 rates. In 2024, Alma faced strong clinician pushback after regional contract renewals with Optum/UnitedHealthcare led to a localized $10 cut in 90837 payouts in states such as Texas and Florida.

Is this REALLY a big deal?

In short, yes, this is a big deal.  Just how much this financially affects your practice depends on your state, your license, and how many Aetna clients you see.  But since Alma has historically paid about $15 to $25 more for a 90837 session than for a 90834, this change could create a meaningful revenue hit for providers who regularly offer longer sessions.  Let’s crunch some numbers:

Estimated loss based on $20 difference between a 90837 and 90834 reimbursement

Number of Aetna 90837 Sessions Weekly
Weekly Loss
Annual Loss (48 Weeks)
5 sessions $100 $4,800
10 sessions $200 $9,600
15 sessions $300 $14,400

 

The sad reality

But the sadder reality may be that when an insurance plan throws its clinicians under the bus like this, it pushes more therapists to leave insurance networks.  And because Aetna is one of the largest health plans in the country, that means therapy becomes even less accessible to the public.  Or if therapists switch from 60-minute to 45-minute sessions, many clients will not get the level of treatment that may be clinically necessary, driving up symptoms to a higher level of overall severity.

 

Will this affect ALL Aetna clients?

Right now, this appears to affect only Aetna clients that are seen through Alma.   Aetna told Behavioral Health Business: “our overarching reimbursement policies related to behavioral health providers and license levels have not changed, nor have our policies related to the reimbursement for mental health services.”  If Aetna has plans to apply these policies outside of Alma, they haven’t made them public.

 

What can you do to fight back?

  • The American Psychological Association (APA) is already aware of the issue and has contacted Aetna directly. The California Psychological Association (CPA) has also emailed its members.  To be part of a broader response, consider reaching out to the APA or your professional association—or join if you are not already a member.
  • Work with Alma on a response:
    • Alma created an anonymous survey to document how these changes are affecting clinicians and caseloads, so they could share this data with Aetna executives.  While initial Alma emails stated that the survey was open until May 29, 2026, later emails from CEO Harry Ritter stated that more than 5,000 responses had already been received, so the survey would be closed Monday, May 25th to enable an earlier formal response to Aetna.
    • Log in to your Alma Provider Portal to review your updated regional fee schedule and to speak up about the impact on your practice.
    • Contact Alma Provider Support to see if they are consolidating appeals, providing template letters, or offering formal guidance on how to protest this or deal with future claims.
    • Consider coordinating with Alma to see if you can file a “Level-of-Severity” Underpayment Appeal with Aetna.  According to Aspirion, Aetna is reducing payment based on what amounts to a clinical coverage determination (e.g. leveling all complex patients to moderate, and underpaying for medically necessary extended sessions).  This may give you the basis for a clinical appeal due to your client’s level of severity.  
  • But: Be careful online.  As with any health plan, sharing Aetna reimbursement rates in an online forum is a contract violation.  Also, online discussions or collective bargaining regarding insurance rates can carry serious legal antitrust risks.  

Update June 12, 2026: The American Psychiatric Association and the American Psychological Association have written a joint letter to Aetna to protest this policy change.  Read about this and read the letter here

Update July 13:  On July 9th, Alma sent an email to members stating that after negotiations with Aetna they were able to “partially reverse” the proposed changes. CPT codes 90837 and 90834 rates will not be the same, E&M codes 99214 and 99215 rates will not be the same, and “reimbursement will continue to reflect degree type and training, rather than being paid at one flat rate.” However, Aetna’s final rates will reflect a reduction overall reimbursement.  Alma acknowledges that this “partial reversal” of their planned changes came about due to push back from Alma members and the professional associations who became involved (so if you ever think advocacy doesn’t work, remind yourself that it can…) Read Alma’s letter here

Are you considering quitting Alma?  Slow down….

Don’t make any rash decisions.  Look into whether you have an annual contract, and when your Alma contract ends.  If you have an annual contract, the Alma website states: “Alma cannot provide refunds for annual plans canceled prior to the renewal date, as stated in our Membership Terms and Conditions.”  But be sure to confirm this.

You may want to consider getting individually credentialed with Aetna, but remember applications take months and acceptance is not guaranteed.  Be sure to download all your session notes before leaving Alma and carefully go through the appropriate resignation process.   

Want to explore other Alma-like platforms?   Grow Therapy, Headway, Sondermind, Uplift, and Path/Rula are reassuring clinicians that that they still have a 90834/90837 rate differential.  Just keep in mind that Aetna could eventually apply similar rules there as well. 

Some resources

  • I have two articles for therapists using or thinking about using platforms like Alma, including questions they should ask first to ensure they are making informed decisions.  I also discuss my concerns about how therapists lose some important control when working with these platforms.  The articles are here and here
  • Psychotherapy Action Network has put together a toolkit for therapists wanting to manage their practice without platforms like Alma, and a second toolkit for therapists using or thinking about using these platforms, including questions they should ask first
  • For an interesting but slightly different take on this issue, read an article from billing expert Susan Frager of PsychBillingCoach.com — her article is here

Read my follow-up article which addresses:  Can you go from providing routine 60-minute sessions to 45-minute sessions without losing something vital along the way?  Get tips on how to decide if this makes sense for your practice, and if so, how to do this ethically, clinically and practically — click here

Get Your Free Copy of the Report

"13 Ways You Might Be Accidentally Committing Insurance Fraud"

Your information will not be shared.

Writing Great Progress Notes Course

WEBINAR: "WHAT'S MISSING FROM YOUR CHARTS: WRITING GREAT NOTES" (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Practice Forms Packet

PRACTICE FORMS PACKET – 24 Essential Forms (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Navigating the Insurance Maze - Cover

2025 10th EDITION! Book: Navigating the Insurance Maze: The Therapist’s Complete Guide to Working with Insurance – And Whether You Should (FOR INFO, CLICK HERE)

Purchase Now

Barbara Griswold, LMFT

Did you find this article helpful? For more like it, subscribe to Barbara's free e-newsletter here.

Barbara Griswold, LMFT, is a private practice coach and the author of Navigating the Insurance Maze: The Therapist's Complete Guide to Working With Insurance – And Whether You Should, 10th edition. Check out Barbara's online catalog of helpful online courses, practice forms, and other therapist resources related to insurance, documentation, and running your therapy business here.